Explorer

SC Refuses CEC Gyanesh Kumar's Interim Suspension, Seeks Response On 'Unilateral Decision'

A bench headed by CJI Surya Kant issued notice to the Election Commission of India and sought its response to the allegations. The court indicated that it could reconsider or recall decisions if the ECI's response establishes that they were taken without the required unanimity.

Show Quick Read
Key points generated by AI, verified by newsroom
  • Supreme Court rejected plea seeking CEC Gyanesh Kumar's suspension.
  • Court issued notice to ECI regarding unilateral decision allegations.
  • SC stated it might recall decisions lacking required unanimity.
  • Petitioner argued CEC acted unilaterally, sought multi-member consensus.

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to pass any interim order suspending Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over allegations that he took decisions unilaterally in the Election Commission of India (ECI), without the consensus of the other two Election Commissioners.

A bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant issued notice to the ECI and sought its response to the allegations raised in the plea.

The court indicated that it could reconsider or recall decisions taken by the CEC if, after examining the ECI's response, it finds that they were taken without the required unanimity.

“After notice, if they come and show that ABC decisions were taken without unanimity, we will take those decisions back,” the court said.

ALSO READ | Delhi Rape Cases: SC Tells Centre, Police To Ensure Women Feel Safe, Strengthen Patrolling

Plea Seeks Suspension Of CEC

Senior advocate Vikas Singh, appearing in the matter, argued that the Election Commission is a multi-member body and raised questions over the manner in which the CEC and Election Commissioners exercise their powers.

Singh also referred to changes in the law concerning the appointment and powers of the CEC and Election Commissioners. He said the law provides them protection from legal proceedings for actions taken during their tenure and gives them powers to determine the procedure for conducting the commission's business.

“I am only arguing today about how election commissioners have been given protection which even the Prime Minister does not have,” Singh said.

He sought an interim order suspending the CEC during the pendency of the proceedings.

ALSO READ | 135-Year-Old Central Secretariat Library Row: Centre Denies Removal Plan, SC Seeks Details

SC Questions How ECI Would Function

The bench questioned how the Election Commission would function if the CEC were suspended.

Singh responded that the two other Election Commissioners could continue to perform their functions.

He also urged the court to at least direct that decisions be taken unanimously while the matter remains pending before the Supreme Court.

The bench, however, said the commission would function according to the law.

When Singh suggested that the court could direct the ECI to take decisions by majority, the bench responded that there was already a law governing the issue.

“We hope that it is being and will be done according to the law,” the court said.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Supreme Court suspend CEC Gyanesh Kumar?

No, the Supreme Court refused to pass any interim order suspending Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. This was in response to allegations of unilateral decision-making.

What action did the Supreme Court take regarding the allegations?

The Supreme Court issued a notice to the ECI and sought its response to the allegations. The court indicated it could reconsider decisions if they lacked unanimity.

Could decisions made by the CEC be overturned?

Yes, the Supreme Court indicated it could reconsider or recall decisions. This would happen if, after examining the ECI's response, it finds they were taken without the required unanimity.

Why was the suspension of the CEC requested?

The request for suspension stemmed from allegations that the CEC took decisions unilaterally. The petitioner argued the ECI is a multi-member body.

Advertisement

Top Headlines

India Backs UN Resolution On Palestinian, Syrian Golan Rights; Israel, US Vote Against
India Backs UN Resolution On Palestinian, Syrian Golan Rights; Israel, US Vote Against
'PM Doesn't Do That': Sam Pitroda Distances Himself From Rahul Gandhi's Phone-Tapping Charge Against Modi
'PM Doesn't Do That': Sam Pitroda Distances Himself From Rahul Gandhi's Phone-Tapping Charge
Keralam Doctor Held For Sexually Harassing House Surgeon At Govt Hospital, Minister Assures Action
Keralam Doctor Held For Sexually Harassing House Surgeon At Govt Hospital, Minister Assures Action
PMK Seeks NEET Review As Only 5% Of Students Under Tamil Nadu's 7.5% Quota Clear Exam In First Attempt
PMK Seeks NEET Review As Only 5% Of Students Under Tamil Nadu's 7.5% Quota Clear Exam In First Attempt
Advertisement

Videos

Surat Fire News: Massive Blaze Erupts at Textile Warehouse, Goods Worth Lakhs Feared Damaged
J&K Weather News: Fresh Snowfall Covers Gulmarg, Bhaderwah & Kathua as Tourists Enjoy Winter Magic
Maharashtra Politics: Deputy CM Sunetra Pawar Meets Devendra Fadnavis Amid NCP Merger Buzz
Godhra Train Fire: Ex-Investigator Rakesh Asthana Calls Sabarmati Express Blaze a Planned Conspiracy
West UP Political Showdown: Yogi, Owaisi & Akash Anand Rally Ahead of 2027 Assembly Elections
Advertisement

Photo Gallery

Advertisement
25°C
New Delhi
Rain: 100mm
Humidity: 97%
Wind: WNW 47km/h
See Today's Weather
powered by
Accu Weather
Embed widget