Explorer

Vice-President Dhankar Slams SC, Says Parliament's Sovereignty Cannot Be Compromised By Judiciary

Dhankhar said that parliamentary sovereignty and autonomy are essential for the survival of democracy and cannot be compromised by the executive or judiciary.

Vice-President Jagdeep Dhankhar on Wednesday questioned the 1973 Kesavananda Bharati case verdict, which established the basic structure doctrine, stating that it sets a bad precedent and undermines parliamentary sovereignty. He also criticized the scrapping of the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act in 2015 by the Supreme Court.

"In 1973, a wrong precedent was set. In the Kesavananda Bharati case, the Supreme Court gave the idea of basic structure saying Parliament can amend the Constitution but not its basic structure. With due respect to the judiciary, I cannot subscribe to this," Dhankhar, a former Supreme Court lawyer, said.

"Can Parliament be allowed that its verdict will be subject to any authority... The executive has to follow laws and the judiciary cannot intervene in law-making. If any institution on any basis strikes down the law passed by Parliament then it will not be good for democracy and would be difficult to say we are a democratic nation," the Rajya Sabha Chairman said.

Vice-President Dhankhar said that parliamentary sovereignty and autonomy are essential for the survival of democracy and cannot be compromised by the executive or judiciary. He argued that the judiciary should not be able to intervene in lawmaking and that any institution striking down laws passed by parliament would be detrimental to democracy.

He specifically spoke about the NJAC Act and said it was an unprecedented scenario in democratic history, where the executive must adhere to laws passed by parliament and the judiciary should not be able to overturn them.

His statement comes in the midst of a debate on the appointment of higher judiciary and the government's criticism of the current Collegium system, which the Supreme Court is defending. Dhankhar emphasized that no institution should wield power to neutralize the mandate of the people.

View More
Advertisement
Advertisement
25°C
New Delhi
Rain: 100mm
Humidity: 97%
Wind: WNW 47km/h
See Today's Weather
powered by
Accu Weather
Advertisement

Top Headlines

'Not In Good Taste', 'No Significance In Maharashtra': NDA Leaders Divided Over 'Batenge To Katenge' Slogan
'Not In Good Taste', 'No Significance In Maharashtra': NDA Leaders Divided Over 'Batenge To Katenge' Slogan
GRAP 3 In Delhi From Tomorrow As AQI Remains In 'Severe' Category. Details Here
GRAP 3 In Delhi From Tomorrow As AQI Remains In 'Severe' Category. Details Here
AAP's Mahesh Kumar Khichi Elected As Delhi's New Mayor Amid Cross-Voting
AAP's Mahesh Kumar Khichi Elected As Delhi's New Mayor Amid Cross-Voting
'Cong Desperate For Power Like Fish Out Of Water': Modi At Mumbai Rally, Takes 'Remote Control' Jibe At Uddhav
'Cong Desperate For Power Like Fish Out Of Water': Modi At Mumbai Rally, Takes 'Remote Control' Jibe At Uddhav
Advertisement
ABP Premium

Videos

Nirmala Sitharaman Announces Game-Changing Collateral-Free Loan Scheme for MSMEsSIP Emerges as a Safe Investment Amidst Market Fluctuations | Paisa LiveTop Banks Offering 8.75% Interest for Senior Citizens: Here’s What You Need to Know!RBI Set to Make a Big Decision on Your EMI: What You Need to Know!

Photo Gallery

Embed widget