Chinmayi Vs Dhee: Social Media Sparks Fierce Debate Over ‘Muththa Mazhai’ Rendition From Thug Life

A debate erupted online comparing Chinmayi Sripaada's and Dhee's versions of "Muththa Mazhai" from the film 'Thug Life' and their respective fans supporting for them.

Chinmayi, a prominent voice in India’s #MeToo movement, has been facing what many describe as an "unofficial ban" in Kollywood.

Source : Instagram

Even as Thug Life, the much-talked-about film starring Kamal Haasan, continues to stir headlines with its controversies, a fresh musical debate has gripped the internet: Who delivered the better version of the song ‘Muththa Mazhai’—Chinmayi Sripaada or Dhee? Originally sung in Tamil by Dhee for the AR Rahman-composed soundtrack, the track also features versions in Telugu (Muddu Vaana) and Hindi (Ang Ang Morey), both performed by Chinmayi.

However, the conversation intensified after Chinmayi delivered a powerful live performance of 'Muththa Mazhai' at the film’s audio launch, drawing enthusiastic reactions from the crowd—and notably, a nod of appreciation from Kamal Haasan himself.

Chinmayi Vs Dhee

Chinmayi's performance quickly ignited social media discussions, with fans and musicians alike comparing her soulful rendition to Dhee’s original.

Dhee, on the other hand, remains a rising star in Tamil playback singing, known for her experimental and emotive vocal style. Her version of 'Muththa Mazhai' in Thug Life has been praised for its delicate balance and contemporary appeal.

Chinmayi's Ban In Kollywood 

The debate comes with a deeper undercurrent. Chinmayi, a prominent voice in India’s #MeToo movement, has been facing what many describe as an "unofficial ban" in Kollywood. After she publicly accused veteran lyricist Vairamuthu of misconduct in 2018, Chinmayi was reportedly ousted from the South Indian Cine, Television Artistes and Dubbing Artistes Union (SICTADAU), resulting in limited opportunities in Tamil cinema despite her acclaimed talent, as per a report on The Hindustan Times.

The film itself is no stranger to controversy. Kamal Haasan's earlier comment suggesting that Kannada evolved from Tamil sparked a linguistic row, adding fuel to the ongoing debates surrounding the movie.

As Thug Life gears up for release, the Chinmayi vs Dhee conversation continues to trend across platforms like X (formerly Twitter), Instagram, and YouTube, with fans passionately defending their favorite artist.