Explorer

Labelling Persons As Encroachers, Deploying Bulldozers Not A Solution: Bombay HC

The bench sought information from the Western Railway, MMRDA, and BMC if they have in place any rehabilitation policy or system, and what are the eligibility criteria.

Merely labelling persons as encroachers and displacing them is not a solution and the issue has to be addressed in a "more considered fashion" than by just deploying bulldozers, the Bombay High Court has said while seeking to know from the Western Railway, Mumbai civic body and MMRDA if they have any rehabilitation policy in place. A division bench of Justice Gautam Patel and Neela Gokhale on February 8 heard a petition filed by Mumbai-based Ekta Welfare Society, challenging the eviction and demolition notices issued to its residents by railway authorities as they were encroaching on its property.

The bench sought information from the Western Railway, Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA) and the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) if they have in place any rehabilitation policy or system, and what are the eligibility criteria.

“Throughout, we bear in mind that merely labelling these persons as 'encroachers' is not going to answer the problem. This is a serious problem in the city and it is a problem of human displacement. Sometimes, the scale of the displacement is beyond the imagination. It has to be addressed in a more considered fashion than by merely deploying bulldozers on the site,” the court said. As per the Western Railway, 101 unauthorised structures have already been demolished till February 7.

The court in its order said the Western Railway and other authorities had not followed directions given by the Supreme Court in December 2021 while such demolition drives are held.

As per the SC order, before commencing the process of eviction and removal of structures, the authorities concerned should record the identity of the occupants of the structure for consideration of rehabilitation.

The apex court had said if the local government has any rehabilitation scheme, then the affected persons should be permitted to apply for the same if eligible.

The high court said the demolition report submitted by the Western Railway does not indicate whether any survey was done of the 101 structures before demolition, which was against the SC order.

ALSO READ: Woman Entitled To Maintenance Even After Divorce Under Domestic Violence Act: Bombay HC

The bench said no further demolition is to be carried out in contravention of the SC order anywhere on Western Railway lands in Mumbai, and posted the matter for further hearing on March 1.

It said the notices issued to the occupants of the petitioner society's structures do not point out any rehabilitation scheme or any requirements of eligibility or how these are to be met or within what time.

"These are not even notices under the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorized Occupants) Act. They are simply eviction notices,” the HC said.

It was also unclear if the Western Railway took up the matter of rehabilitation with the MMRDA or the BMC, it said.

It, however, added that at this stage the court was not indicating that the MMRDA or the BMC was necessarily bound to rehabilitate those ousted in the Western Railway's encroachment removal drives.

As per the demolition report, the debris generated from the demolition drive was thrown outside the railway land at a low lying area.

The court took exception to this and said it does not emphatically approve of this approach.

“The disposal of the debris raises more questions than it answers because by throwing the material into a low-lying area, apparently the presumption is that it will get washed into the Arabian Sea,” the HC said.

(This report has been published as part of the auto-generated syndicate wire feed. Apart from the headline, no editing has been done in the copy by ABP Live.)

View More
Advertisement
Advertisement
25°C
New Delhi
Rain: 100mm
Humidity: 97%
Wind: WNW 47km/h
See Today's Weather
powered by
Accu Weather
Advertisement

Top Headlines

Rahul Gandhi Claims Senior Minister 'Calling, Forcing Businesses To Praise PM Modi' After His Opinion Piece
Rahul Gandhi Claims Senior Minister 'Calling, Forcing Businesses To Praise PM Modi' After His Opinion Piece
Canada Bans Australian Media Outlet For Airing Jaishankar's Presser, India Says 'Hypocrisy Towards Freedom Of Speech'
Canada Bans Australian Media Outlet For Airing Jaishankar's Presser, India Says 'Hypocrisy Towards Freedom Of Speech'
Shah Rukh Khan Threatened By Chhattisgarh Thief? Here's What Mumbai Police Investigation Revealed
Is 'Hindustani', Who Threatened SRK, A Thief? Here's What Probe Has Revealed So Far
BJP Slams Congress Over 'Blank' Constitution Books At Rahul Gandhi's Event In Nagpur, Party Responds
BJP Slams Congress Over 'Blank' Constitution Books At Rahul Gandhi's Event In Nagpur, Party Responds
Advertisement
ABP Premium

Videos

US Presidential Election 2024: 'I Will Fight for Your Future' Says Trump After Election VictoryUS Presidential Election 2024: 'Thank You to the American People,' Says Donald Trump After VictoryUS Presidential Election 2024: Donald Trump’s Address After VictoryUS Presidential Election 2024: 'We Will Make America Great Again,' Says Donald Trump After Victory

Photo Gallery

Embed widget