Explorer

ICC U19 World Cup 2024: Controversy Erupts With ‘Obstructing The Field’ Dismissal In England vs Zimbabwe Clash- WATCH

Controversy arose in the ICC U19 World Cup 2024 as a 'Obstructing the Field' decision sparked debate regarding 'Sportsmanship' during the England vs Zimbabwe match.

In the 38th match of the Super Six, Group 2 of the ICC Under 19 Men’s Cricket World Cup 2024 in Potchefstroom on February 3 (Saturday), England faced Zimbabwe in a game marked by a controversial 'obstructing the field' decision. England, batting first, posted a total of 237/7 in their allotted 50 overs and went on to secure a dominant 146-run victory by dismissing Zimbabwe for 91. However, the match was marred by a controversial incident that raised questions about the concept of 'sportsmanship' in cricket.

The controversial moment occurred in the 17th over of England’s innings when No.4 batter Hamza Shaikh faced Zimbabwe’s left-arm spinner Ryan Simbi. After an unsuccessful stroke, the ball landed near Hamza's feet, prompting Zimbabwe wicketkeeper Ryan Kamwemba to move towards the stationary ball. Hamza gestured with his right hand, indicating that he would pick the ball. He then picked up the ball and flicked it to Kamwemba, who was positioned next to him.

Here's A Clip Of The Controversial Incident:

Although this action is not uncommon in the game, traditionalists often disapprove, suggesting that as a batter, one should leave the fielders to collect the ball, regardless of its location. Kamwemba appealed, leading the umpires to convene and refer the decision to the third umpire, who deemed it out under the 'obstructing the field' rule (Rule 37.4), stating that a batter is out if they use the bat or any part of their person to return the ball to a fielder without the fielder's consent.

Here’s What Rule 37.4 (Returning the ball to a fielder) Of The Laws of Cricket (MCC) Says: 

“Either batter is out Obstructing the field if, at any time while the ball is in play and, without the consent of a fielder, he/she uses the bat or any part of his/her person to return the ball to any fielder.”

The dismissal, perceived by many as against the 'spirit' of the game, sparked widespread criticism on social media. Former England cricketer Stuart Broad expressed his disagreement, stating that passing a stationary ball back to the fielder should not result in an obstructing the field dismissal. Notably, before 2017, this type of wicket would have been categorised under the 'handled the ball' mode of dismissal, but a change in the laws merged the two together.

View More
Advertisement

IPL Auction 2025

Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Virat Kohli
₹21 CR
Josh Hazlewood
₹12.50 CR
Rajat Patidar
₹11 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Rishabh Pant
₹27 CR
Nicholas Pooran
₹21 CR
Ravi Bishnoi
₹11 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Jasprit Bumrah
₹18 CR
Suryakumar Yadav
₹16.35 CR
Hardik Pandya
₹16.35 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Heinrich Klaasen
₹23 CR
Pat Cummins
₹18 CR
Abhishek Sharma
₹14 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Ruturaj Gaikwad
₹18 CR
Ravindra Jadeja
₹18 CR
Matheesha Pathirana
₹13 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Shreyas Iyer
₹26.75 CR
Arshdeep Singh
₹18 CR
Yuzvendra Chahal
₹18 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Sanju Samson
₹18 CR
Yashaswi Jaiswal
₹18 CR
Riyan Parag
₹14 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Venkatesh Iyer
₹23.75 CR
Rinku Singh
₹13 CR
Varun Chakaravarthy
₹12 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Rashid Khan
₹18 CR
Shubman Gill
₹16.5 CR
Jos Buttler
₹15.75 CR
View all
Most Expensive Players In The Squad
Axar Patel
₹16.5 CR
KL Rahul
₹14 CR
Kuldeep Yadav
₹13.25 CR
View all
Advertisement
25°C
New Delhi
Rain: 100mm
Humidity: 97%
Wind: WNW 47km/h
See Today's Weather
powered by
Accu Weather
Advertisement

Top Headlines

Sambhal Clashes: FIR Against Sambhal MP Ziaur Rahman Barq For Inciting Violence
Sambhal Clashes: FIR Against Sambhal MP Ziaur Rahman Barq For Inciting Violence
Parliament Winter Session Live: Lok  Sabha, Rajya Sabha Adjourned Till Nov 27 After Protests To Discuss Adani Issue
Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha Adjourned Till Nov 27 After Protests To Discuss Adani Issue
Yogi Govt, Vishva Hindu Parishad Planned Sambhal Violence For 2027 UP Elections: SP
Yogi Govt, Vishva Hindu Parishad Planned Sambhal Violence For 2027 UP Elections: SP
Nana Patole Resigns As Maharashtra Congress Head After Party's Dismal Show In Assembly Polls
Nana Patole Resigns As Maharashtra Congress Head After Party's Dismal Show In Assembly Polls
Advertisement
ABP Premium

Videos

Parliament Winter Session Starts, Both Houses Begin Proceedings | ABP NewsBreaking News: New Posters of CM Yogi in Mumbai Spark Controversy with 'Batenge to Katenge' MessageSambhal Violence: Autopsy Reveals Shocking Details in Deaths of Two Youths | ABP NewsBreaking News: Priyanka Gandhi Accuses State Government of Mishandling Sambhal Violence

Photo Gallery

Embed widget