Explorer

SC Issues Notice To Centre, ECI On Plea Challenging Blanket Immunity For Election Commissioners

The Supreme Court has sought the Centre and ECI's response to a plea challenging blanket legal immunity granted to election commissioners.

Show Quick Read
Key points generated by AI, verified by newsroom
  • Supreme Court sought responses on plea challenging election commissioners' immunity.
  • Petitioner questions legislative process, potential impact on voters.

The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought responses from the Centre and the Election Commission of India (ECI) to a petition challenging the legal immunity granted to the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and other Election Commissioners. The plea questions Section 16 of the 2023 law, which bars civil and criminal proceedings against election commissioners for acts done in the discharge of their official duties. A Bench led by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant issued notice on a petition filed by activist and lawyer Arun Kumar Agrawal.

Immunity Challenged

The petition argues that the provision grants the CEC and Election Commissioners blanket protection, without exceptions for acts allegedly not carried out in good faith. It says protections available to other constitutional functionaries are generally limited to acts done, or intended to be done, in good faith.

The petitioner contends that the ECI functioned effectively for decades without such blanket immunity. It argues that safeguards against frivolous complaints and prior judicial scrutiny could protect commissioners from vexatious litigation without removing legal remedies altogether.

The plea says voters whose names are wrongly deleted from electoral rolls, candidates affected by allegedly mala fide decisions and citizens raising corruption concerns could be left without an effective remedy.

Also Read: Cabinet Clears Two-Year Extension For 75% of Agniveers; Fresh Chance To Join Armed Forces

2023 Law Questioned

The petition also points to the legislative process behind Section 16. It says the original Bill did not include the immunity clause and that a later amendment introducing it was not supported by adequate reasons.

The petitioner further argues that the parliamentary justification did not establish why such broad protection was necessary or proportionate. It also notes that the Bill was passed when several Opposition MPs were suspended from Parliament.

The plea maintains that the Election Commission's independence should not place its members beyond legal accountability.

SIR Concerns Cited

The petitioner has linked the challenge to allegations surrounding the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, citing Indian Express report about objections reportedly raised by two Election Commissioners and concerns over the software used in the exercise.

The plea also refers to allegations concerning CEC Gyanesh Kumar's earlier tenure as Kerala's Public Works Department secretary.

It questions whether election commissioners should enjoy blanket immunity even in cases involving alleged actions not undertaken in good faith.

The petitioner has urged the Supreme Court to declare Section 16 of the 2023 Act unconstitutional.

Advocate Neha Rathi appeared for the petitioner.

Also Read: ‘Trump Controls Modi’: Rahul Gandhi Challenges PM To Debate, Attacks AAP Over Punjab's Drug Crisis

About the author ABP Live News

ABP Live News delivers round-the-clock coverage of India and the world, tracking politics, policy, governance, crime, courts and breaking developments, while offering sharp, verified reporting that helps readers stay informed, aware and connected to the stories shaping public life.

Read More
Advertisement

Top Headlines

BJP-SAD Alliance Back On Cards; Seat-Sharing Talks Near Finish, Announcement Soon: Report
BJP-SAD Alliance Back On Cards; Seat-Sharing Talks Near Finish, Announcement Soon: Report
'Even Tea, Coffee Can Be Addictive': RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat's Warning On Social Media
'Even Tea, Coffee Can Be Addictive': RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat's Warning On Social Media
Pakistan Handlers And Failed Bomb Attempts: How Rajasthan Railway Blast Was Planned
Pakistan Handlers And Failed Bomb Attempts: How Rajasthan Railway Blast Was Planned
'We Are Still At War': Iran Warns US Against Using Diplomacy To Prepare Another Attack
'We Are Still At War': Iran Warns US Against Using Diplomacy To Prepare Another Attack
Advertisement

Videos

Birsa Munda Jayanti: Congress Leaders Skip Parliament Ceremony, BJP's Pradeep Bhandari Targets Rahul Gandhi
Congress News: BJP's Pradeep Bhandari Calls Rahul Gandhi a 'George Soros Puppet' Over Bharat Summit Remarks
UP Politics: Akhilesh Yadav Faces Poster Row in Agra as SP, BSP Battle for Dalit Votes Ahead of 2027
Agra News: Akhilesh Yadav to Address SP's Dalit Conference, Party Eyes 2027 UP Elections
UP News: CM Yogi Adityanath Inspires Youth in Lucknow, Says India Is the World's Youngest Nation
Advertisement

Photo Gallery

Advertisement
25°C
New Delhi
Rain: 100mm
Humidity: 97%
Wind: WNW 47km/h
See Today's Weather
powered by
Accu Weather
Embed widget