Explorer

Karnataka High Court Sets Aside I-T Seizure Order Of Rs 3,700 Crore Against Xiaomi

The IT Department had passed the order on grounds that the Chinese firm was remitting income abroad in the guise of paying royalty to avoid paying tax in India

In a major relief to Xiaomi Technology India Pvt Ltd, the Karnataka High Court has set aside Income Tax's seizure order of Rs 3,700 crore of the company's fixed deposits.

Justice S R Krishna Kumar in his judgment on December 16 imposed three conditions for setting aside the August 11, 2022, order of seizure of the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax.

The first condition was that Xiaomi "shall not be entitled to make payments from the subject fixed deposits accounts in the form of royalty or in any other form to any companies / entities located outside India." Secondly, Xiaomi is "at liberty to take overdrafts from the subject fixed deposits accounts and make payments from such overdrafts to such companies / entities located outside India." And thirdly, the Income Tax Department was "directed to complete the draft assessment proceedings of the petitioner for the Assessment Years 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22 on or before March 31, 2023."

The IT Department had passed the order on grounds that the Chinese firm was remitting income abroad in the guise of paying royalty to avoid paying tax in India.

A similar order by the Enforcement Directorate freezing Rs 5,551 crore was disputed in court.

Justice M Nagaprasanna reserved the judgement in the ED case on November 17 and it is awaited.

In the IT case, the court found several lapses by the Department.

"A perusal of the impugned order will also indicate that there is no finding recorded as to why a provisional order of attachment had to be passed against the petitioner; it is significant to note that there is no finding recorded by the first respondent that the petitioner was a 'fly-by-night operator' from whom it was not likely to recover the likely demand," the court noted in its judgement.

Quashing the order, the HC said, "In other words, in the absence of any reasons as to why and how the demand would be defeated by the petitioner, mere apprehension that huge tax demands are likely to be raised on completion of assessment was not sufficient to constitute formation of opinion and existence of proximate and live link for the purpose and necessity of provisional attachment which implicate the doctrine of proportionality. Under these circumstances also, I am of the considered opinion that the impugned order deserves to be quashed." 

View More
Advertisement
Advertisement
25°C
New Delhi
Rain: 100mm
Humidity: 97%
Wind: WNW 47km/h
See Today's Weather
powered by
Accu Weather
Advertisement

Top Headlines

Delhi LG Orders Inquiry Into Mahila Samman Yojana, Kejriwal Says BJP Is 'Frustrated'
'What Is The Probe Even About?' Kejriwal On Delhi LG's Order To Inquire 'Mahila Samman Yojana'
'Farewell Manmohan Singh': World Bids Final Goodbye To Man Who Saved India From Economic Collapse
'Farewell Manmohan Singh': World Bids Final Goodbye To Man Who Saved India From Economic Collapse
Watch: Driver Jumps Off As Truck Skids In Snow, Falls Into Gorge In Manali
Watch: Driver Jumps Off As Truck Skids In Snow, Falls Into Gorge In Manali
Nitish Reddy Hits Maiden Test Century, Leads India's Fightback In IND vs AUS Boxing Day Test
Nitish Reddy Hits Maiden Test Century, Leads India's Fightback At MCG
Advertisement
ABP Premium

Videos

Manmohan Singh Funeral: Former PM Cremated with State Honors, Leaves Behind a Lasting LegacyManmohan Singh Last Rites: Sonia Gandhi Pays Tribute to Former PM with Floral OfferingsManmohan Singh Last Rites: President Droupadi Murmu Pays Tribute to Former PM | ABP NewsManmohan Singh Last Rites: Home Minister Amit Shah Pays Tribute to Former PM | ABP News

Photo Gallery

Embed widget