'Dharmendra-Amitabh Na Gunde Lagte Hai Na Bhaade Key Tattu': A Scathing Sholay Review From 1975

Sholay is one of the most loved films of Indian cinema. When it was released in 1975, expectations were sky-high. However, the initial response from critics was far from favourable. 

Sholay is one of the most loved films of Indian cinema. When it was released in 1975, expectations were sky-high. The film was backed by a star-studded cast, including Amitabh Bachchan, Dharmendra, Hema Malini, and written by the legendary screenwriting duo Salim-Javed. This film masterfully combined elements of Westerns, action, and drama within a uniquely Indian context. Directed by Ramesh Sippy, ‘Sholay’ began with a budget of Rs 1 crore, which ultimately ballooned to Rs 3 crores, making it one of the most expensive Indian productions of its time. However, the initial response from critics was far from favourable. 

Many early reviews criticised Sholay for being too long, overly dramatic, and lacking emotional depth. An old review of the film by a magazine has resurfaced on the internet, where the film has been panned by a critic.  

An old scathing review of Sholay

The reviewer notes that the film starts off strongly, even humorously, but begins to falter post-interval, where the narrative shifts towards excessive violence. According to the review, the writing duo of this "khichdi" film, Salim-Javed, seemed to believe that every scene has to be filled with fights and violence. This transition is critiqued for lacking genuine impact; the fight scenes are described as devoid of tension or excitement. While the film attempts to draw inspiration from Hollywood through its set designs, it fails to create an authentic atmosphere. 

The review further critiques the film's production values. For instance, the significance of a water tank in the storyline raises questions about its functionality in a village without electricity or modern conveniences. The review also states that there are many such ridiculous inconsistencies in the film. 

The entire cast of Sholay criticised

The performances of the lead actors are met with disappointment as well. The critic writes in Hindi, “Considering Sanjeev, Dharmendra, and Amitabh as actors who have been in certain types of films, you cannot take them seriously in the roles in 'Sholay’. 

Additionally, the review states, “Dharmendra aur Amitabh na gunde lagte hai na bhade key tattoo (Dharmendra and Amitabh do not look like goons or hireling).” 

The review does not spare the other cast either, as it critiques Hema Malini’s portrayal saying that “She neither looks young nor like a woman.” 

Even the iconic villain, Gabbar Singh, portrayed by Amjad Khan, does not escape scrutiny. The review claims he seems uncertain about whom to imitate, failing to create a convincing menace. 

The review is concluded by stating that though Sholay possesses certain technical merits, it is ultimately considered a flawed film and spending crores on such mediocre films is a sin. 

Sholay's legacy

As time went by, Sholay garnered immense popularity, and its characters, dialogues, and even the infamous Gabbar Singh became unforgettable parts of Indian cinema’s legacy. What began as a critical disappointment has now cemented its place as one of the greatest films in Indian cinema. 

Salim-Javed’s writing, once criticised, is now celebrated for its sharpness, wit, and ability to create lasting characters. The film’s dialogues are quoted to this day, and Gabbar Singh is hailed as one of Bollywood’s greatest villains.