With England's win, Pakistan now need to win their last game against Bangladesh (Friday) and hope that New Zealand beat England in their last encounter on Wednesday so that Pakistan can enter the knockout stage.
"It was for the first time that Pakistani fans were praying for India to win against England. However, it feels like the prayers couldn't reach India as they lost the match," said Akhtar on his Youtube channel.
"It was for the first time since Partition that we were supporting India. I am sure India must have tried their best but their best could not help Pakistan and leave us with a hope," he added
Akhtar felt that the English batsmen made full use of the conditions and exposed the Indian bowling line-up.
Bairstow scored a brilliant 111 and Ben Stokes played a superb knock of 79 off just 54 balls to power England to 337/7.
"The Indian bowlers were completely exposed by Jonny Bairstow and Jason Roy and other England batsmen. I felt that India could have conceded at least 30 runs less. I felt that India could have chased down if the total was around 300. However, it was not the case and we were left disappointed," said Akhtar
"The Indian spinners, especially Yuzvendra Chahal, were taken to the cleaners by the English batsmen," he added.
Akhtar also criticised India's batting approach in the first 10 overs and also towards the end of the innings.
"India needed to get off to a flier during their chase of 338. However, it was not the case and in the mix of things, they started very slowly. And towards, the end as well, they batted very slowly," he said.
"The Indian batting line-up will have to do a lot of thinking as their middle-order is getting exposed quite a number of times in this World Cup.