No Confidence Motion HIGHLIGHTS: Opposition Motion Defeated In Lok Sabha After Voice Vote
No Confidence Motion HIGHLIGHTS: Follow this live blog for the latest updates on the proceedings of Parliament's Monsoon Session.
Background
No Confidence Motion HIGHLIGHTS: Hello and welcome to the live blog on the no-confidence motion debate in Parliament.Amid the ongoing debate on the no-confidence motion brought in by the Opposition...More
No-trust motion loses as LS speaker Om Birla holds voice vote.
Don't use Manipur for politics, understand their pain and become a medicine for it: PM Modi
Today's India does not bow down, it doesn't halt... The world now trusts India because Indians have confidence in themselves. It's an opportunity take the country forward: PM Modi
Parliament is not a mere party platform... I trust the citizens of our country, I believe they have unshakeable faith: PM Modi
Today Manipur's scenario is being presented as if it's a recent occurrence. The woes of Northeast have been birthed by Congress and its politics... Manipur was ailed by separatism during Congress rule: PM Modi
"Whose government was there in Manipur when everything used to happen according to the wishes of insurgent organisations? Whose government was there in Manipur when Mahatma Gandhi's picture was not allowed in government offices, whose government was there in Manipur when the decision to not allow the national anthem in schools was taken?... Their (opposition) pain is selective. They cannot think beyond politics," he added.
On 5 March 1966, Congress sent IAF to attack hapless civilians in Mizoram. To date, the state mourns on this day. Congress hid this truth. They attacked Akal Takth. They killed people's confidence in the Northeast. In 1962, Pdt Nehru said on Nehru 'my heart goes out to the people of Assam'. He left them to their fate: PM Modi
Opposition MPs walk out of the Lok Sabha as Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks.
They divided Maa Bharati into three parts (with partition). They encourage the gang that says Bharat tere tukde honge... Congress party's history has been about dividing the country: PM Modi on Rahul Gandhi's remarks in LS.
Crimes against women were committed, they are 'unforgivable'. I want to assure the country, that our efforts will ensure that peace prevails. I want to tell Manipur that the country and this Parliament are with you. We will find a resolution and Manipur will see peace and progress: PM Modi
Union Home Minister Amit Shah addressed all issues of Manipur without indulging in politics. He attempted to spread awareness, peace: PM Modi
Opposition walks out of PM Modi's address, he says they don't have patience to listen.
Ghamandiya alliance wants India's economic strength to be weakened... people will mend their ways: PM Modi
The same product is being relaunched... the country is calling their pyaar ki dukaan, loot ki dukaan, jhooth ka bazar: PM Modi
In a veiled dig at Rahul Gandhi, PM Modi said: "The country knows his mental state, now they know what their heart is like."
It stings you (Opposition) why a poor man's son is sitting on this (PM) seat... There was time when clothes were sent by air for dry-cleaning today, today people with Hawai slippers are traveling by air. Naval ships were used for private celebrations, today they are being used to bring Indians back: PM Modi targets Gandhi family.
Opposition alliance biggest representative of dynastic politics... Congress likes parivarvaad and darbarvaad: PM Modi
It's not INDIA alliance, it is 'ghamandiya' alliance and everyone wants to become Prime Minister: PM Modi
They set up programmes with their own names and did corruption worth crores: PM Modi
A Tamil Nadu minister said the state is not a part of India... when such people are a part of alliance where will this coalition head to: PM Modi
INDIA stole NDA and inserted I of arrogance. They also broke up the name INDIA with I.N.D.I.A.: PM Modi
Door yudh se bhagte nam rakha randeep, bhagya chand ki aaj tak soyi hai takdeer: PM Modi
Opposition tried to show an old rusted vehicle as modern electric vehicle: PM Modi on INDIA alliance.
Oppn raises slogans of 'We want Manipur' as PM Modi hits out at Congress's election performance in Lok Sabha.
India's people have no trust for Congress, they are so arrogant they can't see the floor they stand on: PM Modi
The history of Congress has been that they have never believed in the potential of the country. They believed in Pakistan's words. Their love for Pakistan was such that he used to immediately believe the words of Pakistan. They used to believe Pakistan: PM Modi.
Congress may think progress happened with a magic stick, but reform, perform and transform as well as hard work which is why India is where it is.. New reforms will be introduced as per requirement: PM Modi
When you bring no trust motion in 2028, India will be among three richest economies: Modi
A responsible Oppn would have asked for a roadmap to make India the world's third highest economy, but Congress says it doesn't require any work, it will happen on its own. Congress doesn't have any intention and vision: PM Modi
The doomsday prediction they make for every org, it ends up seeing progress... they don't have faith in the country's hard work, potential: PM Modi
They said HAL and India's defence sector are destroyed... today, HAL is seeing new limits of success. They tried to instigate HAL workers but today the org is India's pride: PM Modi
Opposition used as many unparliamentary words as they could. People curse me night and day, their favourite is 'Modi teri Kabra Khudegi (Modi your grave will be dug)'.. I make their words as a tonic and drink it... They have a secret blessing, whoever they wish bad for ends up benefitting. I am an example: PM Modi
Opposition including Congress in disbelief of India's progress... They are not able to see people's trust: PM Modi
Opposition trying to unsuccessfully hurt people's self-confidence with this no-trust motion: PM Modi
We gave India a scam-free government, India's youth opportunities to soar high, enhanced India's reputation worldwide: PM Modi
The 21st century period brings the opportunity to fulfill India's period, we are in a time period that is very important, It's impact with last for 1,000 years. What the country achieves now with its dedication and efforts will benefit it for 1,000 years. Our biggest priority should be the country's development: PM Modi
Adhir babu (Congress MP Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury) wasn't given the opportunity to speak, it's your benevolence that you allowed him to speak while there was a time constraint. However, he still knows how to ruin an opportunity: PM Modi
The country is watching you, hearing what you say, but you have only disappointed the country: PM Modi.
PM Modi criticises Opposition for not participating in discussions on bills pertaining to Data Protection, Dalits, and more.
"Opposition has betrayed the citizens... They have shown parties are primary than nation. You have hunger for power, you don't care about the future of the youth, but your own," he remarked.
PM Narendra Modi Speech Live: Prime Minister thanks the citizens for showing faith in his government. "People say God is very kind... I treat it as God's blessing that Opposition brought this no-trust motion.. I said in 2018 that it wasn't a floor test of the government but their (Opposition) floor test," he said.
"Today, I can see that you (Opposition) have decided that NDA and BJP will come back with a grand victory, breaking all previous records, with the blessings of the people," he added.
PM Narendra Modi Speech Live: Prime Minister replies to No-Trust Motion in Lok Sabha.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Congress leader Rahul Gandhi return to Lok Sabha.
BJP MP Rajyavardhan Rathore says the Congress should be "tried for treason", as he alleged their government was run on "remote control" by the Communist Party of China.
PM Narendra Modi Speech Live: Prime Minister to reply to No-Trust Motion in Lok Sabha at 4 PM.
Union Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia says,"...Mujhe 20 saal ho gaye hai iss sansad mai lekin aisa drishya maine do dashak mein nahin dekha hai...Pradhan Mantri ke prati jo shabd istemal kiye gaye hai vipaksh ke dwara mai manta hu sadan ke samne nahi lekin desh ki janta ke samne maafi mangni chahiye... (In my 20 years in this Parliament I have not seen anything like this. The words used by Opposition for the Prime Minister, they need to apologise for it.)"
"The last nine years have been the most peaceful in Manipur from the insurgency point of view. There has been three times lesser insurgency and six times lesser civilian deaths as compared to your (Congress) 10 years of rule," says Union minister Jytiraditya Scindia in Lok Sabha.
"The PM gave a sensitive statement on Manipur outside the Parliament but they (opposition) insisted that (PM) gives a statement in the House. The Home Minister said time and again that we are ready for a discussion on any given date and time. However, they did not let the House function for 17 days," says Union minister Jyotiraditya Scindia.
"The people of the country have shown them (Opposition) the exit door, now they are going out of the Lok Sabha as well, " he remarked.
"They (opposition) are ready to speak, but not ready to listen. They don't want to listen to the people of the country or this House," says BJP MP Jytiraditya Scindia during no-confidence motion debate in Lok Sabha.
The Opposition staged a walkout from Lok Sabha over Congress MP Adhir Chowdhury's address being interrupted.
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi on Congress MP Adhir Chowdhury comparing PM Modi to Nirav Modi says "...Baseless allegation against the Prime Minister cannot be accepted. This should be expunged and he should apologise"
Congress MP Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury says "Jab Dhritrashtra andhe the, tab Droupadi ka vastra haran hua tha, aaj bhi raja andhe baithe hai... Manipur aur Hastinapur mein koi farq nahi hai. (Droupadi was disrobed as Dhritrashtra was blind, today too the King is blind. There's no difference between Manipur and Hastinapur.) "
The Lok Sabha speaker expunged this remark.
As PM Modi entered Lok Sabha today, Congress's Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury said that the power of no-confidence motion has brought the Prime Minister to the Parliament.
The Pharmacy (Amendment) Bill, 2023 to amend the Pharmacy Act, 1948 was passed in the Rajya Sabha today. The Bill was passed by the Lok Sabha on August 7.
While speaking in Lok Sabha, Mahua Moitra said that the people of this country have lost confidence in PM Modi after his inaction on the Manipur issue.
TMC MP Mahua Moitra says "India has lost confidence in you (PM Modi). The spectacle of the prime minister of the greatest democracy bowing to religious Seers of a majority in the chamber of the new Parliament fills us with shame, police manhandling and filing FIRs against champion wrestlers fills us with shame, 50 Panchayat in 3 districts of Haryana issuing letters forbidding Muslim traders entering the state fills us with shame. 'Nafrato ki jung mein ab dekho kya kya ho gaya, sabziya Hindu hui aur bakra Musalmaan ho gaya'. One crony capitalist is not going to make a monkey out of India's regulators and Equity markets while we watch. Everyone asks if not Modiji then who? After this inaction on Manipur, India will say, anyone but Modi."
TMC MP Mahua Moitra says "We are here to ask the question in our 'tum abhi chup raho' republic where the PM tells a Governor 'chup raho'. We as elected MPs in this House are routinely told 'chup raho'. This motion is to break this code of silence in Manipur. PM Modi will not listen to us, he will come on the last day and give his speech. I don't know what is more unfortunate, our PM refuses to come to the Parliament or that he refuses to go to Manipur"
TMC MP Mahua Moitra has begun her speech in the Lok Sabha.
Taking a dig at PM Modi, AIMIM MP Asaduddin Owaisi said that if the PM gets to know that the term 'Quit India' was coined by a Muslim, he would refrain from using the word.
Owaisi says "Our Home Minister was talking about 'Quit India' yesterday. I wonder if he gets to know that the word 'Quit India' was coined by a Muslim, he will not use this word. I want to say that the kind of politics you (Central govt) are doing will harm the country. I want to ask the PM if Hindutva is more important than the country."
Rahul Gandhi reached Parliament ahead of PM Modi's reply on the no-confidence motion debate.
Sitharaman in Lok Sabha said that PM Modi restored Sengol to its rightful place.
Union FM Nirmala Sitharaman says, "...When PM Modi restored it (Sengol) to its rightful place in Lok Sabha, that became an issue, that is an insult of the Tamils. The Senglo was ignored for decades. The Senglol was lost in history and kept in some museum. The Kashi Tamil Sangamam showed how Tamil Nadu and Kashi have very deep connections. The first time you heard Tamil being quoted in the United Nations. In 'Mann ki Baat', PM has used Tamil so many times."
Speaking on rising tomato prices, Sitharaman said that tomatoes are being procured from tomato-growing regions of Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, and Karnataka and are being distributed across the country through cooperative societies like NCCF and NAFED.
Sitharaman says, "Procuring of tomatoes from tomato growing regions of Maharashtra and Andhra Pradesh and also Karnataka and distribution of these through cooperative societies like NCCF, NAFED are all happening. Bihar, West Bengal, Uttar Pradesh, Delhi and Rajasthan - this has already started from 14th July and this will continue. Also in Delhi, mobile vans are distributing as outlets of NCCF and NAFED and also the Kendriya Bhandar."
Congress, NCP and DMK MPs stage a walk-out from the Lok Sabha as Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman speaks on the No Confidence Motion.
Sitharaman took a dig at UPA saying that the BJP govt is cleaning up the mess in the banking sector created by the UPA government.
"We have realised that the banking sector needs to be healthy and therefore we took a lot of measures. Banks are able to work without political interference, they are working with professional integrity. 'Banks mein failaya hua aapka raita hum saaf kar rahe hai'," she said.
Union FM Nirmala Sitharaman said that it is tough to understand whether I.N.D.I.A coalition is fighting against each other or together.
"People moved no confidence against UPA in 2014 and 2019 and defeated them. The situation will be the same in 2024. HM said yesterday, what was the need to change the name of UPA?...They have an amazing unity. It is tough to understand if they are fighting against each other or together," she said in Lok Sabha.
"Transformation comes through actual delivery, and not through spoken words. You show dreams to people. We make their dreams a reality. We believe in empowering all and appeasement of none," FM Nirmala Sitharaman says.
Union FM Nirmala Sitharaman says, "Words like 'banega, milega' are not in use anymore. What are the people using these days? 'Ban gaye, mil gaye, aa gaye'. During UPA, people said 'Bijli aayegi', now people say 'Bijli aa gayi'. They said 'gas connection milega', now 'gas connection mil gaya'...They said airport 'banega', now airport 'ban gaya'..."
"Global economy grew just over 3 per cent in 2022 and the World Bank is now forecasting that it will decline to 2.1 per cent in 2023," says Union Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman in Lok Sabha.
Nirmala Sitharaman said, "In 2013, Morgan Stanley had included India in the list of five fragile economies of the world. India was declared a fragile economy. Today, the same Morgan Stanley upgraded India and gave it a higher rating. In just 9 years, the economy rose and saw economic development due to the policies of our govt - despite COVID. Today, we are the fastest growing economy of the world."
Finance Minister Sitharaman is speaking in Lok Sabha on no-trust motion debate. Prime Minister Narendra Modi will be taking part in the discussion at around 4 PM this evening.
Rajya Sabha proceedings have adjourned till 2 pm. Speaking in the House, Rajya Sabha LoP Mallikarjun Kharge said, "Pradhan Mantri ke aane se kya hone wala hai, kya parmatma hai kya woh? Yeh koi bhagwan nahi hai."
Lok Sabha has been adjourned till 12 noon due to Opposition protests over Manipur issue. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman and PM Modi are set to speak on the no-confidence motion later today.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi holds a meeting with Defence Minister Rajnath Singh, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi and Union Ministers Piyush Goyal and Arjun Ram Meghwal to discuss the government's strategy in Parliament. PM Modi is likely to reply to the debate on no-trust motion in afternoon.
A meeting of floor leaders of INDIA parties is being held in the Rajya Sabha LoP chamber in Parliament to chalk out the strategy for the floor of the house. Today, PM Narendra Modi will reply to the debate on no-confidence motion in Lok Sabha.
Speaking on the no-confidence motion brought by the Opposition, BJP leader RP Singh says, "The reason why they (opposition) have brought the motion is not known...But PM Modi will answer all the questions that will be raised...They are using the Manipur issue to relaunch INDIA. The video (Manipur incident) was released a day before the Parliament session and there is definitely some politics involved in the timing of the release."
Several bills are set to be moved in Rajya Sabha today. Union Minister of Law and Justice Arjun Ram Meghwal will introduce the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Bill, 2023. He will also move the Repealing and Amending Bill, 2023, for consideration and passage to repeal certain enactments and to amend an enactment. Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya will move the Pharmacy (Amendment) Bill, 2023, which was passed by the Lok Sabha on August 7.
"...The whole nation is watching how Union Home Minister spoke on Manipur & opposition's no-confidence motion, this shows that though the opposition lacks confidence, people of this country have confidence in Modi govt", says BJP MP Jagdambika Pal on Union Home Minister Amit Shah's response on the Manipur issue in Lok Sabha, as quoted by news agency ANI.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi will on Thursday address the Lok Sabha on the no-confidence motion tabled by the Opposition in the Lower House of the Parliament. The motion was moved by the Opposition in an attempt to corner the Modi government on the issue of Manipur. The motion was admitted by Lok Sabha Speaker and was debated on Tuesday. The ruling National Democratic Alliance faces the no-confidence motion — although not a threat considering the comfortable majority — again after Telugu Desam Party moved a similar motion in 2018.
Modi's address comes just a day after reinstated Congress MP Rahul Gandhi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah spoke in the Parliament on the motion. Rahul Gandhi, who spoke first, launched an all-out attack on the Bharatiya Janata Party-led Central government over the Manipur violence. During his fiery speech in the Lok Sabha, Gandhi alleged that India had been murdered in Manipur.
"You are putting the entire country in flames. First, it was Manipur, now it is Haryana. You want to burn the whole country," Gandhi said in his no-trust vote speech in Lok Sabha.
Later Amit Shah took the stage and addressed the Manipiur issue and also spoke about terrorism in Kashmir and Naxalism in central parts of India. Addressing the Lok Sabha during the debate on the Opposition’s motion of no-confidence against the Centre, the Union Home Minister said, “Only when a CM stops cooperating with the Centre, could he be changed. The present (Manipur) CM (N Biren Singh) has been cooperating with us.”