9 Top-Rated Murder Mystery Movies SE7EN IMDb Rating– 8.6/10 SHUTTER ISLAND IMDb Rating– 8.2/10 PRISONERS IMDb Rating– 8.1/10 GONE GIRL IMDb Rating– 8.1/10 THE FUGITIVE IMDb Rating– 7.8/10 THE GIRL WITH THE DRAGON TATTOO IMDb Rating– 7.8/10 ZODIAC IMDb Rating– 7.7/10 MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS IMDb Rating– 7.5/10 Bad Times at the El Royale IMDb Rating– 7.1/10